Should I sell my Rolex?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

ETenebris

O.G.
Feb 4, 2006
8,208
191
In January of this year I toyed with the idea of selling my midsize Yacht Master SS/platinum for a midsize DateJust. There is a size difference, of course...the DateJust midsize is 31mm, while the YM midsize is 35mm, and I am not a skinny girl. I have tried the 36mm DateJust, but it is too big and looks like a man's watch on me.

The plusses are: 1. Cute/sporty/blingy; 2. I sometimes use the rotating bezel if I need to time something (mostly parking meters!); 3. It IS the only "sport" watch Rolex makes for the ladies; 4. It is sort of "under the radar" as Rolexes go, so you don't see many around; and 5. It seems to be gaining in popularity.

The minuses: 1. Can be bulky when wearing a suit; 2. Fairly heavy, so it doesn't stay where I would like on my arm much of the time; 3. I got it at a good price because it was a less popular model at the time; 4. It was my first new Rolex; and 5. The price just increased across the board at Rolex, so if I regretted selling, it would be very hard to replace it for what I originally paid.

Should I keep it and just feel a bit clunky sometimes when I wear it with suits? Should I sell and get the two-tone DateJust which is the "standard" Rolex? I am asking because I have a Rolex enthusiast acquaintance who has expressed an interest in buying mine for his wife, so I guess I have to make a decision one way or the other.

Here is a pic of the watch on (this is my "optimal position" but when I am walking around the watch "falls" down onto my wrist and is loose. I have never had it sized. And another pic of just the watch.

DSC02068.jpg


DSC01639.jpg
 
I'm not knowledgeable about watches, but to me it sounds like if you just got it sized, you would be happy with it. It's nice to have something more rare / under the radar, and the bigger size is a plus in my book. Plus, I think it suits you.
 
Of course I love the yachtmaster since I have same one. But I only wear mine when I'm casually dressed. If you only want one watch and it needs to span wearing a suit to more casual, the midsize DJ is probably a better bet.
 
Rockerchic, yes, I HAVE been wrestling with this for a while! I had settled on keeping the YM until I got the offer, which started me thinking again. (Never a good thing!) I think the size of the YM is perfect for me, while the midsize DJ is a bit on the small side and the 36 looks too much like a man's watch on me. Wondering what made me pick the YM originally, other than I did like the sporty/chunky feel. I feel a weird attachment to it as my first new Rolex...like it would be terrible to get rid of it somehow...but that's must me being sentimental and silly, I think.
 
LOL - I believe you tried to talk me into the YM when I bought my mid-size! And now you're considering the mid-size?! I tried on the YM several times. Too busy on the face. I do like it though on others. Would you get a very decent price for it? If you took a bog loss, I would just keep it. But that is JMO.
 
I love your YM and it looks great on you. Why don't you have a few links taken out and wear it around for a week or so and see if that makes a difference to you or not. Then decide whether to do something different.
 
Top