Have you tried on the tan color instead? I had a similar dilemma before I bought my puzzle (light caramel / sand mink / tan) and somehow tan is the easiest to match with my clothing. I think it’s either because of the leather, that the tan looks more casual than the other two. Also, light caramel seems to be more “yellow” and warm toned that might not match with your skin tone.
I am very happy with my tan in the end. I couldn’t match it with my pink / pastel clothing though. However, I find it more versatile than the other two that I considered buying.