My small Mint Puzzle with gold HW is about two years old and the metal still looks fine. I don’t use it constantly though.
It doesn’t feel or look bulky to me when I wear it but that’s one of those very subjective things. I’m 5’4” and I generally don’t like bulky bags at all. Obviously it does have a boxy shape. Wherever you’re buying from make sure returning is easy just in case.
Both bags you’re considering are gorgeous neutrals but if you want to change shoulder straps with other Loewe straps you might have more options with platinum hardware - that’s been my experience anyway.
Thank you for telling me your experience

The advice regarding the silver hardware is very helpful and I find that silver seems more modern.
Thank you again
