Rogue or Burberry

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#16
I have only one Burberry leather item (that I am aware of- I won't even go there......:biggrin:) Made in Italy and it is amazing quality. The glazed edges have held up better than my LV.

You should buy what makes you happy- it is a big investment. All of the bags you mentioned are gorgeous- love them all- follow your :heart:
 
#18
I have the matching burberry black gold buckle wallet, but i vote Rogue...its so versatile and the color is very neutral. The burberry yellow is striking, and a completely different design, its smaller and has more character. You would have to plan your wardrobe though since it is not as neutral/versatile as beechwood. Both are gorgeous bags. If you have the black mohowak simon rexy, it would look awesome with the yellow burberry. Just saying. I guess im no help ;(
 
#19
You're going to have a bit of biasness towards the rogue since we're in the coach forum. It depends what you prefer...casual or classy....I do find the burberry classier than the rogue...the rogue's slouchy structure gives it a more casual look.
 
#20
I vote for Rogue tea rose.
I have the tea rose rogue of a different color. i've been used for 2 months now basically everyday. There is no ware and tear at all. It's roomier than the Burberry. That Burberry is cute, but the size seems to be a weekend bag, that you can't fit many to it. While Rogue regular size is a working horse, it can be your main bag.

Also, you can find very similar design to the Burberry bag from many brands, but the tea rose is so unique. I know lots of brands start making flower embellish bags, but none of them has the same craftsmanship detail as coach tea rose.
 
#24
I am not sold on the Rogue flowers, but I like the Rogue in general.

I have a Burberry wallet and was not impressed with durability and most importantly the after-care support. All of my Coach after-care experiences has been amazing, and that is what pushes it over.
 
#25
Is it for a special occasion or everyday? Personally, I absolutely love my rogue. However I have a plain oxblood (red) rogue without the flowers. The flowers are a bit much in my opinion so I would have to lean towards the other bags. I couldn't decide between the two other bags though because they don't really do anything for me. The coach and other bags are very different, from "look at me" to blend in.

I would recommend taking a second look at the rogues with no flowers. They're very versatile and you can add bag charms to make them your own. Here's a picture of mine below with some bag charms.
X.jpg
Good luck deciding, please let us know which one you end up getting! :smile:
 
#26
Is it just me or are we kind of comparing apples to oranges? They're very different bags, and probably significantly different in size (correct me if I'm wrong here). The Coach one is very pretty, the color allows it to be worn with many things and during all seasons, although the flowers kind of make it best for spring/summer. It depends on how much you love the flowery aesthetic, because someone who doesn't love it will get bored of it. The Burberry color is less practical and the bag itself is much smaller (I think) but besides the color I think it's more timeless perhaps. Not a huge fan of the shape though.

We would need to know more of what kind of bag you're looking for and what your personal tastes are. The most beautiful bag to me might be unappealing to someone else and vice versa. :p

If you're just looking for a summer bag, I'd personally go with the Coach
 
  • Like
Reactions: pianolize
#27
OP posted in March, so I imagine she has something figured out by now!

(though my vote would be for Rogue; while I would tire of the flowers if it were my only bag, I doubt I would ever get bored if it were in rotation...and I am not a very flowery person!)
 
#29
I wonder too- and see the dilemma since they are all totally different bags!!! (Perhaps I am not the one to ask, since my pinks collection is ridiculous. I honestly think they are all COMPLETELY different.) :facepalm:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top