Yes, that's the one. I honestly don't know if that seller is selling fakes either because, as I said, I've not seen one irl but I do know that Coach does sometimes change little details on their bags as they go. Just playing devil's advocate since I don't have the necessary knowledge to authenticate the Rogue bags. It also seems like (especially that embroidered Rogue) they would be rather hard to duplicate.
Rogue, are there fakes?
- Thread starter Marie Lee
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
Yes, that's the one. I honestly don't know if that seller is selling fakes either because, as I said, I've not seen one irl but I do know that Coach does sometimes change little details on their bags as they go. Just playing devil's advocate since I don't have the necessary knowledge to authenticate the Rogue bags. It also seems like (especially that embroidered Rogue) they would be rather hard to duplicate.
Her feedback actually looks good, someone negged her for not shipping an item so I don't know what happened there but the neg wasn't claiming that the bag is a counterfeit. They've actually sold several Coach bags including Swaggers, Mickey, etc.
Again, have no idea if those are all fake bags but I would be surprised if they were.
Again, have no idea if those are all fake bags but I would be surprised if they were.
They have 15 positives, the majority being nail polish! Lol, pretty hard to mess that up. Those two listings (nma) for Rogues were fake.
Not here to argue with you Hobbsy. I imagine of all the Coach bags that she's sold that if they were received and deemed fakes that the buyers would be complaining somewhat. I also notice that there was one Rogue bag that was presented here for authentication on the AT this Coach forum and there was no answer given as to it's authenticity.
I think even the real authenticators have a hard time finding a fake one. Maybe one of them can chime in here and let us know for sure.
Not sure what you're looking at, but I don't see any Coach bags she/he has sold besides the last two?!?!?
You need to go into her sold listings to see them.
I've also been trying to find ANY site that may be selling a bag that remotely looks like the Rogue and I can't seem to find anything like it......so if hers are indeed fakes I'm wondering where they came from.
Do you guys think these two are real or fake? http://m.ebay.com/itm/New-Coach-Rog...%3Ac981884d1570a5e0a74915b9ffff4199%7Ciid%3A4
I thought the only bags with the lock were the first generation rogues and they all had pebbled leather on the handles and where the zipper is? That's how mine are anyway. Once they removed the lock on the side they used a lighter weight smooth leather on zipper and handles.
I agree, fake - second generation colorway, 1st gen was black with brass hardware, and the second gen don't have the locks. I had this exact bag and it did not have a lock.
Just a heads up, there are many times that Coach first generation bags have subtle differences
Thank you for pointing this out.........!
Last edited by a moderator:
Wow, I would never be able to tell that this one is fake
Last edited by a moderator:
This seller has 2 fake rogues listed on eBay. Here is one the listings http://m.ebay.com/itm/New-Coach-Rog...PLEASE-READ-/332005639759?nav=WATCHING_ACTIVE
If you look at her active listing and feedback she is selling the same stuff as the seller who sold the embroidery rogue. http://m.ebay.com/itm/New-Coach-194...eather-57230-/262651716986?nav=WATCHING_ENDED
If you look at her active listing and feedback she is selling the same stuff as the seller who sold the embroidery rogue. http://m.ebay.com/itm/New-Coach-194...eather-57230-/262651716986?nav=WATCHING_ENDED
