And before Benedict was Pope John Paul II. Now that was a tough act to follow! And I think Benedict did it well. You can leave it to the NYT to slam Benedict in terms of the clergy sexual abuse scandals in addition to his adherence to hardcore Catholic doctrine . Fact is, it was Benedict that brought attention to those scandals, the first Pope to do so. It's a Pope's JOB to carry out Catholic doctrine, not revolutionize Catholicism to present day touchy-feely, "my truth" vs "other people's truths", or cater to individuals who act as though the world should revolve around them.