Please help me decide! Bulga Crescent Bag - Ruched or Not ruched?

[diana]

#1 ruched!

 

[lucretias]

I guess I'll be in the minority. I like the 2nd.

 

[Sarsi]

I like the 1st one.
It looks more attractive to me.

 

[cs06]

They are both beautiful, but when looking at the two of them together, I prefer the first one (with rouching). I think it shows off the quality and depth of the leather better.

 

[Superbaby]

It reminds me of the dolce gabbana bag that i just got..

 

[Superbaby]

I like both though..

 

[eyelove]

I vote for Style 1.

The extra pocket on Style 2 makes the bag look a bit too busy - it gives off the impression that the pocket was quickly tacked onto the bag.

 

[lucretias]

^^^Interesting that's the main reason I like #2. I love the extra bag on the side. I have a bulga pudding bag and love the little flap pocket on the front. The ruching makes it seem to too busy to me. Hmm, I feel so out of the majority. Maybe I need to reconsider my taste!

 

[spiralsnowman]

Thanks guys, I have ordered one in a Cognac color... It arrives Friday! Your advice has been great