Please help me decide! Bulga Crescent Bag - Ruched or Not ruched?

[spiralsnowman]

I would love some opinions on this... Should I should get this Bulga satchel in the style with ruching/gathering along the top, or the one with a smooth top? Any and all thoughts welcome!

Note: The one w/out ruching has 2 tassels, the other has only 1.

Style 1 (Ruched, 1 set of tassels)



Style 2 (No ruching, 2 sets of tassels)

 

[icechick]

I like the first one, the second kind of looks like it's pregnant, to me that is

 

[LisaG719]

I prefer the ruched one. Cant explain why - something about it seems for appealing.

icechick - your pregnant comment made me crack up!

 

[uhkiwi]

#2

 

[annabelle]

I like the first one (with the rouching) the second one looks too plain...

 

[LVgirly]

I like #1

 

[BrownPaperBag]

the first one. The pocket on the second one looks too busy.

 

[Compass Rose]

The first one is really attractive. The second one looks like a taco.....but a nice taco, though.

 

[wickedassin]

I think the rouched style looks better. It gives the bag a little "something."

 

[asl_bebes]

I agree with the majority ... the first one looks better, the ruching detail makes the bag a little more interesting.

 

[essential]

no. 1

 

[minicoop]

I vote for the first!

 

[Audrey]

I prefer Style 1.

 

[passerby]

No: 1.

 

[SuLi]

Another vote for the ruched bag!