I don't think the duffle and #2 look too similar - different accents and completely different styles. However, if you're like me and you've noticed a "pattern" with your bags (when looking at my collection recently I found that I apparently really like brown and gold - almost every purse I own is some variation of those colors!), you may want to branch out. I happen to like the pebbled one a little more, but I'm just now going from not being a signature lover to really liking signature pieces, so that's probably just personal bias. I do think #2 is gorgeous!