Just want to revive this thread and see what people's thoughts are after having these bags for a while. I just bought the duffle 20 in the glovetanned saddle and am trying to decide whether to keep it or not. I'm usually a pebbled leather girl, but I have been loving the latest Coach Originals line. I've seen pictures of the duffle 20 in pebbled leather, and it looks like so soft and smooshy, whereas the duffle 20 in glovetanned leather looks more structured. For those that have had the duffle 20 in glovetanned leather, do you find that it has softened up over time and gotten more smooshy, or does it generally stay more structured? Also, have you gotten a lot of scratches on it, or how has it worn over time? Any thoughts (and pictures) would be greatly appreciated.