One-Brand-Only Ladies! Please tell us about it!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I completely get why some people would have a hard time understanding how some of us can buy only one brand and be happy. I happen to be a "one brand girl" and sometimes I think it's a little weird, but it makes me so happy, so why not? To answer OP's questions...

Are you someone like this?
Yes, mostly I have Valentinos, I have two Marc Jacobs.

Do you know anyone like this?
There's one other V girl who I think comes close to my single minded adoration.

How does one get to be this way?
I actually used to have tons of different designer bags... Marc Jacobs, Prada, Donna Karan, D&G, Ferragamo, etc. But I always wanted a Valentino. They were just so freakin pricey! Finally one day I did buy a Valentino (after selling a few of my other bags) and that was it. I pretty much knew I wouldn't go back to another brand. That first bag made me so happy, I can't even describe it. It was everything I was looking for in a bag; function, size, color, and most importantly, it was absolutely beautiful!

What do you like about being this way? What is a challenge?
I like that one brand makes me happy. When I want to look for a new bag, I don't have to narrow down the brand, just choose from the many bags available and made by Valentino. My SAs know that I only want Valentino so when they get something in, they know to call me (especially if it's a return and on sale for a good price!!) It's a challenge because, as some of you may know, about a year ago, Valentino introduced a major shift in their bag style. Studs. It was completely different from anything they had done before and it was like your favorite sports team brought on a rookie player that's the new star. For a long time I resisted, but a few months ago, I decided to give the Rockstud collection a try, and now I LOVE it! I have three rockstud bags and two pairs of shoes.

Is it a discipline, or does it feel effortless to you? Why?
Completely effortless. It doesn't even come close to being a discipline. If it did, I would never do it.

Are you tempted to stray to other brands? Do you give in? Why or why not?
Usually no. For awhile, I was considering trying H and Chanel, but I decided against it in the end. All I kept thinking was "I could get a Valentino bag and a pair of shoes for what I would spend on a new Chanel". So I knew I wasn't ready to switch brands, or branch out. Last month I saw a beautiful D&G at Neiman Marcus. I actually considered it, but again decided against it. In reality, it looked very similar to Valentino style and I realized that was the only reason it caught my eye. Why buy something that looks like the brand I love? Just stick with what feels right :D
 
I used to only buy LV. Currently i have 7 bags and out of which 2 are LV. I have set a new rule for myself: 1 brand 1 bag. I realise i like variety but i have limited $ and closet space so i need to restrain myself. Funny enough i do only wear 1 perfume everyday though :laugh:
 
I usually hang out on the coach forum but I am forum jumping tonight and saw this thread. I have many bags of many different brands.....not real expensive..... like dooney, B makowsky, BCBG etc. and never had much interest in Coach for years. However, earlier this year a friend of mine and I went in the Coach store and I started getting this longing to own one. I found the large Madison Sophia in patent camel and ordered it and quickly became hooked on that particular type of bag. I have since collected 3 more Sophias, but unfortunately Coach has quit making the large style and that is the style I love. They replaced it with the Lindsey (in my avatar) of which I now own 1. In the future my only plans are for Coach. It's within my price range so that I can get several bags a year and I have so many other bags that if I need a particular color or something I will switch out my Coach but I don't do it very often. I have sold many of my other bags this year to simplify my life and to help purchase Coach bags. BTW....I'm not into coach for the logo......all but 1 of my bags is leather and logo-less and my purple op-art has a subtle logo....you can see my bags in my signature. So it's not the logo I'm attracted to, I actually don't know what exactly keeps bringing me back to Coach but I am hooked :)
 
Are you someone like this? I have had a bunch of different bags but I have always loved Patricia Nash bags. I have 8 PN bags amd one that is not, a crossbody, but I am looking to replace it with PN crossbody. So I can be fully PN.

Do you know anyone like this? When my mom was alive. She owned one bag and wore it until it wore out then would buy another bag.

How does one get to be this way? I look for quality and I think PN is a quality bag. I know a lot of brands start out being quality then that starts to dwindle with time. Unless PN starts to go down in quality I will be sticking with her brand.

What do you like about being this way? PN's bags are vintage in style and they are unique.

What is a challenge? I do not have any challenges.

Is it a discipline, or does it feel effortless to you? Why? So far this has been effortless. When I choose a bag I always grab a PN bag.

Are you tempted to stray to other brands? Do you give in? Why or why not? So far no temptation. I feel that PN bags are quality bags. I honestly do not care where it is made. I have had bags that are made in Europe and have damaged after the first wear.
 
Top