Ahahaha! You sound like me! I love both, and I really like when a bag can keep a structured bottom and the sides are mostly upright but kinda bend and slouch while still standing. I know this is asking a lot for a bag lol But I think that’s why I have fallen for the Rogue, it hits all my requirements! I know the Clarkson isn’t super structured but when it comes to crossbody bags that I would use on the weekend I like this style too! And the leather looks squishy and yummy. I’m keeping an eye on this bag, can’t wait to see reveals!