Is it closer in size to Edie or Edie 42? I agree about Dalton, I have the black/signature one that I will be returning soon. The leather is really lacking imo, Cass looks like beautiful smooshy leather. I have a few really large charms that I'm hoping would work great on it. They move around and are too noisy on my crossbody bags. Hoping a shoulder bag would cause them to stay put better and be a bit more quiet lol.I bought this one in that brown color, and yes, I really do love it. I've thought about buying another one, but haven't done so. Leather is good quality and comparable to Edie. Plus I love the lock and other features. Now I haven't used a charm on it, but the Cass is much better that Coach's new iteration of the Edie with the Dalton. To me, the Dalton is lower quality, and I just don't care for some of the changes. But that's just me.