Mulberry Roxanne: in or out?

[vicky]

I do think the original Roxanne will remain a classic. Then, there are the seasonal editions of the bag that are trendier and will be dated faster - like the S/S 07 black patent Roxanne with studs by Giles - super hot right now, but not a classic imo. (pic from luisaviaroma.com)

 

[misslola]

I have the Rosemary in Oak, and I love it. The Roxanne is a bit too big and heavy for me, but this is just right. I have gotten many compliments on it as well.