I've had my Ebury for about a year. I wear it sporadically (I change my bags a lot depending on my mood and how much I need to carry) but I haven't been easy on it at all. It's been carried in the rain and on crowded public transportation, and it's held up beautifully. Mine is black so it won't show dirt, but the leather doesn't look scratched at all, just maybe a little softer. Here's a recent photo:
View attachment 2608037
As you can see, the leather doesn't remain quite as stiff as, say, the
Prada Saffiano -- you can see the bag bends in a little on the sides when it's not full -- but the leather has a sheen to it that feels more luxurious to me than Saf. leather. HTH!