I am loving my older handbags but only own two or three different models in multiple colours:
Natasha (full size): Cordovan, Salmon
Natasha (small): Cordovan, Black, Cement,
Natasha PTTM: Newsprint, Raspberry, Nude, Distressed Brown, Brown
Natasha PTTM pouchette: black
Stam: burgundy starburst python embossed, silver hw
Your collection is incredible!

I'm the same way in that I have a few doubles (this is the only brand where I've bought multiples of the same bag in different colours) and I absolutely love my older MJ bags.
My collection in order of purchase:
1- MBMJ Natasha (large with zippers ) in army green with snake strap/sides (found a pic of it but this one is papyrus:
https://picclick.com/Marc-by-Marc-Jacobs-New-Q-Zippers-Natasha-264423429232.html)
2- MBMJ small Natasha in 'India Ink' (which is a beautiful deep navy)
3- MBMJ Ligero Double Percy in burgundy
4- MBMJ Ligero Double Percy in black
5- Marc Jacobs small Recruit crossbody in a royal blue
6- Marc Jacobs small Madison in green with blue accent trims
I also own a couple of small bifold wallets (quilted leather in black and burgundy, both from the men's collection and they never seem to show any wear and tear), as well as several MBMJ bits of jewelry. Oh and a couple of pairs of shoes (mouse flats and dog sneakers).
I missed out on the MBMJ Goodbye Columbus crossbody which I really loved because I couldn't find the right colourway at the time, and there was an MJ reversible zip bucket bag that I wanted a few years ago but it looked like a lunch pail on me, so I never bought it.
I'm sure I'll find more to add to my collection soon enough, as these are by far my most used bags and they only seem to get better with time. Until then, I've got a good enough variety in terms of sizes, models and colours to keep me going until I find something that really makes my heart happy.
I love seeing everyone's collections on here though, and I love that others can rock the bags that I know I can't wear myself. Shame that this sub-forum doesn't move as quickly as the others because, imo, MJ bags are freaking awesome.
