Question…for those who have the larger MAB and the mini MAB (are these the right names?) which do you prefer? Is the larger one too large?
I think you're going to get mixed replies since people like both here.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
Question…for those who have the larger MAB and the mini MAB (are these the right names?) which do you prefer? Is the larger one too large?
here's an old thread on the subjectGood to know about shoulder wear! That’s important to me too. Thanks for the input!
and I should add most of the MAMs do have the optional shoulder strap. but I prefer to carry with handlesI should add that it does carry better on the shoulder (except I have a MAM with longer handles) and also it's the wider depth of the bag that feels too big on my body. Love them on other people though!
Yes, agree, the larger one is better (for me). Every time I buy a MAM I regret it! The MAB is my 'it bag' for sure.I prefer the larger one. I think a lot here also do. The large MAB has a larger outside pocket and carries better on the shoulder. But some here have both. I think the season and the leather makes a big difference here. So possibly some who prefer the large will also go for a mini if it's great leather.
Is the large too large? that's an individual choice. I find sometimes I love a large bag for function but have doubts about it in proporation to my size (5'4")
I had several MAM's back in the day and eventually sold all of them. they are not a tiny bag by any means and proportionally they're probably better on me but I like the MAB betterYes, agree, the larger one is better (for me). Every time I buy a MAM I regret it! The MAB is my 'it bag' for sure.
Yes, exactly!! And really, it's not that much bigger....but you get that amazing 'slouch factor' with the MAB that you just don't get with the MAM.I had several MAM's back in the day and eventually sold all of them. they are not a tiny bag by any means and proportionally they're probably better on me but I like the MAB better
I prefer the smaller ones as you can wear them crossbody with the shoulder strap. MABs are IMO too large to wear crossbody.Question…for those who have the larger MAB and the mini MAB (are these the right names?) which do you prefer? Is the larger one too large?
That MAC looks so good! I used to have one exactly like it and then I sold it. Seller's remorse...I recently bought my first MAM from the Real Real - thanks again Antonia for encouraging me! It was a steal at $51 all in (including shipping and tax, with a coupon). I wanted one of these SO BADLY back in 2008/2009 but couldn't afford/justify it, so I'm thrilled to have one now! Turns out I just had to wait 15 years!I sought out a MAM with soft, somewhat textured leather and the chunky zippers because I have a very well-loved MAC with those features that is like an old friend to me - it was my 2010 splurge and was my only purse other than a school tote for several years.
The Real Real said that this bag's condition was "good" and listed a lot of flaws, but I think it's in great shape! Some hardware scuffing and a bit of interior discoloration but no major issues - much better than I expected. I did wash the interior and apply some leather conditioner when I received it.
Photos!
View attachment 5738219
It did come with the tassels but I prefer to remove them (I know, blasphemy).
View attachment 5738220
View attachment 5738221
Here's my old MAC borrowing MAM's strap for a new and less blingy look:
View attachment 5738222
And with its original strap:
View attachment 5738223
On a related note, would Brasso or any other polishing agent help with this tarnished hardware? I loved this bag HARD for years (and I was younger and less careful with my stuff then...) so it's looking rough.
View attachment 5738224
would it be possible to shorten the strap to a length that might be better? maybe @Shelby33 has an ideaGot my celestial "crossbody" Edie flap. I love everything about it except the strap. The strap drop is 19 inches which is too short for me. The listing said it was 21 inches. No. Hits me at the hip so it looks like I have a beautiful growth on my hip. I'm keeping it because it's gorgeous (leather is soft and supple, old brass HW is lovely and has a good weight), but I'm not sure if it will survive my next closet clean-out.
If anyone sees a full sized Edie celestial on the bay or posh, please let me know!
View attachment 5757156View attachment 5757157
I want to add length to the strap. I guess I could take it to a cobbler/jeweler and they could add links to the chain, but that's another chunk of money. It's not a big deal. It'll just be another dinner date bag.would it be possible to shorten the strap to a length that might be better? maybe @Shelby33 has an idea
very pretty bag - different
Wow, that's gorgeous!! Your pics look way better than the online pics!! I sometimes wear my cross body in front of me rather than on my side (or even more towards my back). Would that work better??Got my celestial "crossbody" Edie flap. I love everything about it except the strap. The strap drop is 19 inches which is too short for me. The listing said it was 21 inches. No. Hits me at the hip so it looks like I have a beautiful growth on my hip. I'm keeping it because it's gorgeous (leather is soft and supple, old brass HW is lovely and has a good weight), but I'm not sure if it will survive my next closet clean-out.
If anyone sees a full sized Edie celestial on the bay or posh, please let me know!
View attachment 5757156View attachment 5757157
Oh i want this! I love itGot my celestial "crossbody" Edie flap. I love everything about it except the strap. The strap drop is 19 inches which is too short for me. The listing said it was 21 inches. No. Hits me at the hip so it looks like I have a beautiful growth on my hip. I'm keeping it because it's gorgeous (leather is soft and supple, old brass HW is lovely and has a good weight), but I'm not sure if it will survive my next closet clean-out.
If anyone sees a full sized Edie celestial on the bay or posh, please let me know!
View attachment 5757156View attachment 5757157
I can try it.Wow, that's gorgeous!! Your pics look way better than the online pics!! I sometimes wear my cross body in front of me rather than on my side (or even more towards my back). Would that work better??