Mini Jodie vs Mini Pouch 20?

Which do you like the most?

  • BLACK Mini Jodie

  • LINOLEUM Mini Jodie

  • LAVENDER Mini Jodie

  • BLACK Mini Pouch 20

Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Mei90

Mei90

Member
Dec 20, 2017
583
422
#1
Hi guys,
I have 2 questions:

1. Which do you like the most between these 4 bags?

Mini Jodie in Black
1206749_in_1365_q80.jpg copy.png
1206749_ou_1365_q80.jpg copy.png

Mini Jodie in Linoleum
428.jpg

Mini Jodie in Lavender
051_1121ef00-54be-45b7-b947-e8a6c184d8ce.JPG

Mini Pouch 20 in Black
Bottega_Veneta_Black_Intrecciato_Nappa_The_Pouch_20-1_1024x1024.jpg copy.png
DavidLTBMinibag_1A_1024x1024.jpg copy.png


and

2. If you could choose 2 from these 4 bags, which would you choose?

2 Jodie (which color?)
or
1 Jodie (which color?) & 1 Mini Pouch 20?

Thanks!!

Disclaimer: all pics from Google
 
#3
Esthetically speaking and color wise it’s a matter of personal preference. I’d just like to point out that the mini Jodie fits much more. At least in the original shape. Haven’t seen the new mini Jodie shape in real life. But I prefer the old shape anyways so I guess black or linoleum
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mei90
#4
Since you're comparing 3 Jodie bags to 1 pouch bag, it seems like you're leaning toward a Jodie. Even if you got a pouch, you would probably still want a Jodie. Out of the colors you've listed, I'd personally go with black, although lavender is also really tempting. Since the bag has to be hand-carried, and our hands aren't always pristine, in the long run the black handle would probably show less wear/dirt.

Let us know what you decide!
 
  • Like
Reactions: goodatlife, J.T., wisconsin and 1 other person
#5
Also depends on whether you plan on carrying your phone in it. I have an 11 pro max and fits in my the 2nd gen mini Jodie (like the black or linoleoum) A few youtube reviews out there that show the mini jodie fits more than the mini pouch
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mei90
#6
Euclase said:
Since you're comparing 3 Jodie bags to 1 pouch bag, it seems like you're leaning toward a Jodie. Even if you got a pouch, you would probably still want a Jodie. Out of the colors you've listed, I'd personally go with black, although lavender is also really tempting. Since the bag has to be hand-carried, and our hands aren't always pristine, in the long run the black handle would probably show less wear/dirt.

Let us know what you decide!
Click to expand...

This is definitely something to consider! :yes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mei90
#13
Minie26 said:
now im undecided to get the mini pouch 20 in either black, sandalwood or kiwi
i really like kiwi in some pics.... just worried that it is too neon tho
Click to expand...
Personally I prefer the mini pouch in light colours, I think we see better the "intrecciato" work. I haven't seen the kiwi colour before. It looks nice! It depends also on your collection... Do you already have a lot of neutral bags? They also have the "buttercup", not as neutral as sandalwood neither the "neon" tone of kiwi.
 
#14
Lugrau said:
Personally I prefer the mini pouch in light colours, I think we see better the "intrecciato" work. I haven't seen the kiwi colour before. It looks nice! It depends also on your collection... Do you already have a lot of neutral bags? They also have the "buttercup", not as neutral as sandalwood neither the "neon" tone of kiwi.
Click to expand...

I don't really have that much neutral coloured bags... or black bag... i do have more white bags tho ...

Oh yes i saw buttercup pic, but i didn't really like it tbh, at least not in the photo.
i think sandalwood is prettier than buttercup?

but whenever i see kiwi in some pics, i feel like its so pretty and fresh,
do you think the smooth leather kiwi would be less neon?
Or is it not a good idea to get the mini pouch20 in the smooth leather?
intrecciato is more classic?

i just worried that, in the long run, i would regret getting the kiwi and wishes that i had gotten it in black or sandalwood , coz they are more safe color? do you think kiwi is totally not neutral? thanks so much!

585852VCP403520C.jpg45530846RS_16_lp.jpg
 
#15
Perhaps it would help you to decide if you have a look to your wardrobe? Do you have a lot of neutral coloured clothes (kiwi would spice it up)? Or do you have a lot of different colours, floral, prints etc? (In this case a neutral bag is easier to match)
And you can also take in consideration the colour of your new Jodie?
You can never go wrong with the sandalwood. It's a very elegant tone of beige, intrecciato looks classic, it's easy to match... But I have the impression that you are looking for different colours (when I see your choices for the Jodie bag), am I right? ☺️
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top