TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
Cinder vs Dark Dune
I was actually kind of surprised how similar they are. Cinder is cooler and a little darker, DD warmer.
Love these two neutrals!
Cinder vs Dark Dune
I was actually kind of surprised how similar they are. Cinder is cooler and a little darker, DD warmer.
Love these two neutrals!
Are you keeping both? I couldn't choose, that's a tough one!
I would say the one on the right from the MK site.
This is a pic of mine which is pretty darn close:
View attachment 3146535
Is your peanut a medium? It looks slightly smaller. I'm trying to decide on size now, although medium only is in black right now. Which size do you prefer?
Yep, peanut is medium. I like both of them, and I don't really notice a huge difference in their size. The pale blue definitely holds more, but it doesn't really seem much larger than peanut. It just seems that the "large" is taller than the "medium" by a couple of inches. I posted some comparison pics in the reference library- those should give you a better idea
ETA: it is post #17 in the "bag size comparison" thread.
Thanks!!! I'm 5'3 and about 112 and trying to decide between the two sizes. I haven't seen medium in person yet. I'd love black with silver hardware but it's only in large; it sounds like there's not a huge difference though so that's good. I don't mind gold, but black and silver is edgier to me [emoji5]️
I tried on medium and large at Macy's and she took the stuffing out and the difference was very minimal. I'm 5'5 120. And I think it looked good. I would go for it if you like the large.
Thank you! The large didn't seem huge when I tried on the peanut; I guess since it's a softer bag it seems less like luggage than the stiffer bags. Did you get one?
I didn't because they didn't have any iris in stock. Now I'm waiting for another sale I really want the steel gray and black.
Large Selma in violet vs medium Selma in wisteria
Large Selma in violet vs medium Selma in wisteria
Large Selma in violet vs medium Selma in wisteria