I am having the same experience with Manolos. I normally wear a 40 - go to Saks the other day and try on a few pairs. The sizing ranged from a 40.5 to a 38.5
ush: Most of the time, every pair I tried on was too big. I tried on a pair of point-toed mules that were on sale in a 40, and they were huge! I bought the silver Sedarabys in a 39, which I guess shouldn't surprise me, because d'orsay styles can run large.
Maybe vanity sizing for shoes is a growing trend?
I like the fact that I can fit into a 39. It's like buying a pair of pants in a 2, when I normally wear a 6 

Maybe vanity sizing for shoes is a growing trend?

