I have to divide mine into purchases from H directly and purchases from secondhand/resellers.
From H itself:
What? Danseuse ballet flat in noir
Bought for? work
Live up to expectations? yes, they are comfortable and stylish
Use and CpW? I wear them about once a week so I think I'm getting good mileage out of them
Love, like, or ride or die status? Love!
What? Clair de Lune shawl in marine/rose
Bought for? I had a silk CdL scarf but I found silks just weren't "me" so I sold it and bought a shawl instead; it's more casual and works well in my wardrobe
Live up to expectations? Yes, it's thin but warm
Use and CpW? Still pretty new to me so have only used it a few times but it's a classic I know I'll have forever
Love, like, or ride or die status? Love!
What? Santorini sandals in rose porcelaine and noir
Bought for? I got these in the fall/winter because they are so stinkin' hard to find in the summer months
Live up to expectations? I haven't worn them yet but I know I will get a lot of use out of them come spring
Use and CpW? N/A
Love, like, or ride or die status? Too soon to tell
What? Gaby 60 sandal in blanc
Bought for? I wanted a heeled summer sandal
Live up to expectations? These gave me awful blisters on the top of my feet
Use and CpW? I wore them once and sold them because they were so painful
Love, like, or ride or die status? Just simply DIE
OK and on to secondhand H purchases:
What? Halzan 31 in Gris Perle
Bought for? I already have a Halzan 31 in a diff color and have always wanted something in gris perle
Live up to expectations? It's a beautiful bag but I was having issues with color transfer so decided to sell it
Use and CpW? Only used a few times, sadly
Love, like, or ride or die status? Like, but not for me
What? Marwari PM in Bleu Electrique
Bought for? Under the radar H bag in a color I've always wanted
Live up to expectations? Yes! It's so functional and easy to carry
Use and CpW? I got this for a steal and use it all the time
Love, like, or ride or die status? Ride or die!
What? Garden Party PM in Vert Amande
Bought for? I love this color and thought a GP would be a great work tote
Live up to expectations? The leather, color, all wonderful - but the GP handles are not long enough to fit over my shoulder so this wound up being too annoying to carry regularly
Use and CpW? Sadly, only used a little bit before I decided to rehome