I just got the whiskey shoulder bag and love the sytle. The strap does fit comfortable on the shoulder but I wish it was a little longer. The satchel is beautiful piece and one I liked the most but you can get it on the shoulder but without a coat on. The Mandy was big and I do not like real big bags but also beautiful and fit the best on the shoulder. I have back and shoulder problems so I really have to watch what I buy. If i could carry the satchel better on my shoulder I would have gotten that piece.