Legacy Brown vs. Legacy Whiskey

What do you think of the Legacy Brown vs Legacy Whiskey?

  • The Whiskey is a MUCH better color.

  • The Brown is a great color and I like it!

  • I like both the brown and whiskey equally.

  • I don't like either one.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Ok, what's weird is that the Coach site doesn't show that the Ali is available in Brown. :confused1: Maybe that means other legacy bags are available in brown as well, but they're just not posted. I just may have to call Coach and ask. ;)
 
I'm surprised at how much I'm liking the brown based on your photos. I know someone else said that they didn't love the brown when they saw it on Coach.com, but did here and I feel the same way - it just seems to have more depth IRL than online. I still love the whiskey, but it's so neat how they both have a completely different look!
 
Will you? And let me know, please!

Ok I called the Coach 1-800 number and found out that the Ali, and Shoulder Bag is available in Brown. The Mandy is not available in brown. They also said that the legacy leather framed slim envelope is also available in Brown. There may be other items available in Brown as well, but I didn't ask further than this. I REALLY wish it was available in the Mandy!

So, yes, the Brown is available in more than just the Ali and Satchel. :smile1: It's also in the Shoulder Bag and the Slim Envelope Wallet. :yes:
 
I'm surprised at how much I'm liking the brown based on your photos. I know someone else said that they didn't love the brown when they saw it on Coach.com, but did here and I feel the same way - it just seems to have more depth IRL than online. I still love the whiskey, but it's so neat how they both have a completely different look!

I was the same way at first - I wasn't fond of the Brown from the website. But it's much different in person than it shows online. It's a deep, pretty Brown. I do like it. But I'm also a huge fan of the Whiskey. :yes:
 
Ok I called the Coach 1-800 number and found out that the Ali, and Shoulder Bag is available in Brown. The Mandy is not available in brown. They also said that the legacy leather framed slim envelope is also available in Brown. There may be other items available in Brown as well, but I didn't ask further than this. I REALLY wish it was available in the Mandy!

So, yes, the Brown is available in more than just the Ali and Satchel. :smile1: It's also in the Shoulder Bag and the Slim Envelope Wallet. :yes:

Thank you for the info! Although that was not the answer I was looking for! I am really thinking that I want my Mandy to be brown instead. Not because I don't like the whiskey. I think I should have gotten the whiskey in a less expensive bag.

What should I do? Return whiskey mandy for brown ali? Even though I already have a black ali? BUT the ali is my all time favorite bag!!!!!!! Aughghgh! I need to think . . . . The whiskey is really pretty though.
 
Thank you for the info! Although that was not the answer I was looking for! I am really thinking that I want my Mandy to be brown instead. Not because I don't like the whiskey. I think I should have gotten the whiskey in a less expensive bag.

What should I do? Return whiskey mandy for brown ali? Even though I already have a black ali? BUT the ali is my all time favorite bag!!!!!!! Aughghgh! I need to think . . . . The whiskey is really pretty though.

To be honest, it wasn't what I wanted to hear either. :sad: I *desperately* wanted the Mandy to come in Brown. I think it would look just GREAT with all the hardware on it (especially since the Brown Satchel just didn't work for me - the style wasn't what I was used to).

I'm afraid I can't be much help to you though - because I'm trying to make the same decision. :confused1: I'd LOVE to have a Mandy, but since it's not being made in the brown I may just go with Whiskey and then exchange my Whiskey Ali for a Brown one. But I keep changing my mind about it too. Arrrrgggghhhhh!!!! Curses Coach for making our decisions harder! LOL

Oh if only the Mandy came in Brown. *dreams of a Brown Mandy* :sweatdrop:
 
Top