Kelly Twilly Bag Charm
- Thread starter Meta
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
It’s going to be hard to find them I’m sure as everyone’s going to want them.
I think they're adorable, but I'd also never pay that much.
I don’t think you’re in the minority at all! I think they are silly too.
C
Clearblueskies
Add 1 more to the minority
I’m in agreement with you, I think they’re silly too!
You are so elegant. It reminds me of this hahahahahaha
Attachments
I know it's not for everyone, but I'm so obsessed. I love how it opens. Favloves posted this video of the charm (third item):
I can't wait until this is released.
I can't wait until this is released.
While they maybe "cute" as miniatures, but I think the idea of a kelly charm is fast becoming a cliche.
Sorry this may sound harsh (and with no intention to offend anyone on here).
I am struggling to see the craftmanship or fine details in these chams, as one would expect from a normal size kelly.
At their best, these charms look hastily put together, resembling a copy or a half finished Kelly to me.
Like others have pointed out, it has been done before by other brands and if I remember correctly Fendi has also done micro bag charms which resemble a lot more like their normal counter part with the finer details of their original sized bag.
Maybe in person the kelly charms would have better appeal, but my initial reaction is not a positive one at all.
Sorry this may sound harsh (and with no intention to offend anyone on here).
I am struggling to see the craftmanship or fine details in these chams, as one would expect from a normal size kelly.
At their best, these charms look hastily put together, resembling a copy or a half finished Kelly to me.
Like others have pointed out, it has been done before by other brands and if I remember correctly Fendi has also done micro bag charms which resemble a lot more like their normal counter part with the finer details of their original sized bag.
Maybe in person the kelly charms would have better appeal, but my initial reaction is not a positive one at all.
As someone who collects miniature bags, including the Fendi you posted
, I do feel like there are some details on the Kelly charm that were overlooked. I have one of their micro bags from SS17 and know the level of detail they can add when so inclined. However, to work on this scale requires an incredible amount of adeptness that often surpasses larger items. I can only imagine the price if it actually had all of the detail of a Kelly. For this price, the working sangles and tiny feet are sufficient.Anyway, no offense taken. I think your assessment is accurate; I merely have a different reaction.
Cute but not for me. They come with mini twillys attached? Too cutesy and for that price I'm partway through a nice vintage Kelly, or a mini K.
I look at it now and I’m like meh. But I am certain if I see it in person I will be ALL over it. I just don’t like it on another kelly (To be fair I don’t like anything on a kelly though). Maybe as a tooth fairy bag to collect teeth? I don’t know what to use it for, but I’m sure if I were to be so lucky to get one I will think of something.... is it big enough to hold a car key perhaps?
I don’t know what to use it for, but I’m sure if I were to be so lucky to get one I will think of something.... is it big enough to hold a car key perhaps?
I think they’re very cute, but no way at that price. I have been eyeing these on Etsy though. Ok, so not Hermes (and they’re not labelled as such) and you can’t open them, but I can’t imagine you could fit anything in one anyway and at this price I think I can cope with that!
