Kelly 25 and 28 on 5’1 sizing help!!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I am roughly 5’2” and a size US 4. I currently own only a B25 but went to Fashionphile to try the B30, K25 and K28. The Vert Jade is the K25.

View attachment 5746771

View attachment 5746774

View attachment 5746775

View attachment 5746780

These comparison photos are excellent.
To my eye they show that hand-held either size works well and the difference is not significant.
It is a different matter when used cross-body with a short strap.
The 28 then dominates the chest and the 25 is preferable.
If the strap were longer the bag would hang at waist level which would be a lot better. 880 shows this very well in post #5.

From a security point if view I can understand that cross-body can be a good idea. Aesthetically when bags, almost regardless of size or gender of the carrier, are across the chest, they look constricting.
Decades ago when Kellys started to be worn with shoulder straps; they hung down from the shoulder and the strap did not cross the body.
Perhaps not such a good idea from a security point if view.
This explains why the standard strap can feel short.
 
Im also 5.1 and have bags in both 25 and 28. the 28 sellier seems a big/boxy for my frame...the retourne 28 is fine for me...as i prefer selliers i stick size 25 more often now.
 
Hi everyone!! Thank you so much for all of your help I ended up ordering this beauty from rebag!! The 25 is definitely the perfect size for me as I prefer smaller bags, but the 28 also would’ve worked! I wouldn’t have been able to feel ok to make this purchase without everyone’s help in sizing, thanks again

(Also, just had a procedure done on my face so don’t mind the redness)

View attachment 5775465

View attachment 5775466

View attachment 5775467
Love your blue shirt - may I know where it’s from?
 
Hi everyone!! Thank you so much for all of your help I ended up ordering this beauty from rebag!! The 25 is definitely the perfect size for me as I prefer smaller bags, but the 28 also would’ve worked! I wouldn’t have been able to feel ok to make this purchase without everyone’s help in sizing, thanks again

(Also, just had a procedure done on my face so don’t mind the redness)

View attachment 5775465

View attachment 5775466

View attachment 5775467
Love your bag, We are Kelly twins! I am 5 feet tall and have used a Kelly 28 sellier for a few years but always felt it was a little big for my body. I recently got this swift Kelly retourne in 25 and feel like it’s the perfect size
F7995CC4-934F-4B68-8141-D46A8EF30E89.jpeg094B2D16-425F-4370-BDC8-6286E0FE255D.jpeg
 
Love your bag, We are Kelly twins! I am 5 feet tall and have used a Kelly 28 sellier for a few years but always felt it was a little big for my body. I recently got this swift Kelly retourne in 25 and feel like it’s the perfect size
View attachment 5775953View attachment 5775957
Swift leather was never on my radar, but I am obsessed. It seems very forgiving!! Also, love the dior sling backs!!
 
Swift leather was never on my radar, but I am obsessed. It seems very forgiving!! Also, love the dior sling backs!!
Thank you! Those J'adior pumps are super comfortable. I've been accumulating different versions but seem to wear the plain black the most.
Swift for a kelly was never on my radar either! It's a little high maintenance but I am loving how light weight it is.
 
I am the same height as you. I wanted k25 but took the k28 anyway since it didnt look big when my SA showed it. Years later I am still trying to get a k25 as it is the perfect size for me. Good luck deciding
 
I’m sure people have mentioned too that the bag looks bigger or smaller depending on the retourne or sellier style. I am 5’3 and have a K25 sellier and it’s a great size but I’m looking for a K28 in retourne as my next bag. I also wear an Herbag 32 that is a little slouchy and that works fine but I recently gave up a K32 sellier cause that’s just too big.

You can see with this Fashionphile image that the width is a little different for sellier vs retourne (at least appearance wise): 1683267745278.png
 
I’m 5’2 and size 38 chanel, Hermes, dior 40-42
what I wear depends on my mood and need for stuff
i prefer sellier, and I usually but not always wear the bigger bags in the winter
with heavier garments

25 K sellier Bleu orage
25B sellier gold
28 K quadrille
28BBK retourne
32K box bordeaux, brushed phw
30B swift gold
35B metallic gunmetal
35B toile
View attachment 5745481View attachment 5745484View attachment 5745486View attachment 5745523

View attachment 5745488View attachment 5745480View attachment 5745482View attachment 5745483View attachment 5745485View attachment 5745487
 
Hi everyone

I’m new to the Hermes world and am looking to buy one preloved!! I would love to see photos of 5’1 with the Kelly 25 & 28 sizes. I’m a bit nervous that the 28 will be too big… any insight is greatly appreciated
If you're still looking for input, there's an amazing thread that I referenced when buying both my K25 and B30. Hope this helps.

 
Top