Getting the larger size is what I recommend. As we age, our fingers also tend to get thicker. You can get a silicone little ring thing to wrap the bottom of your ring with to make the ring smaller. The great part is the comfort fit since silicone is very soft and flexible and it stays on well. You don't feel it at all. It looks like a Slinky toy. I got it online and the pack came with different thickness for rings of different widths. I use mine all the time since my fingers swell and shrink multiple times in a day. I have a JUC ring that I bought preloved that fits tightly on my pointer finger. To me, it looks the best there but the digging of the nail head can be very uncomfortable. The next best thing is to wear it on my ring finger instead but it sometimes can be a bit loose on that one. That is why I use the silicone device on the ring in order to make it fit there.
Thank you for this info! I purchased a small JUC ring right after Christmas and I feel like it's the slightest bit too big, but I could never go down a full size. Going to order the silicone spacers now!
