I think they are different enough to justify having both! Love them. I don't think you would ever regret having a plain black go to pair, even if Hawaiian is similar.
Thank you! This is my thought process as well. While they look similar they are still two completely different styles and colors, of course.

You will never have too many IM Bekkets. To add more varieties, maybe a pair of all leather black Brian instead?
I'm perplexed by the Brian for some reason...I wonder if I'm the only one that finds them kind of hip-hop looking? Not a negative thing so much as a styling thing for me, like I won't wear them right. I don't know what it is..

I saw some discussion of the Bekett if it is jet black or dark gray black. Yours looks like has some variations of Blacks which makes it interesting. As the above mentioned, Brian would be a great options as well since it is all leather and will fit your feet like gloves. I tried on both but decided to keep Brian since they are SO comfy to wear, compare with the suede Bekett. No matter what, you have mile long legs and pull off any shoes you wear.![]()
Yes! The variation is awesome. I thought for sure they'd just be jet black all over but I was pleasantly surprised to see the different types of black represented.


I think they're too similar... how about the cream/off white ones? They're also pretty easy to wear and really look different from the ones you already have. The Brians are nice too and less similar, but also black and I would go for something really different.
I saw the cream ones at LaGarconne! Kinda bummed they're not the stone ones from the previous Season(s). I wish they had an Anthracite type color...something with greys! Then I'd be in trouble. Or if they brought back the cobalt blue ones. I would just

They both look great, but I do agree that you don't NEED both pairs....but...
Haha, I love your reply. That "but..." says a lot! I played dress up in my closet last night and I think I'm going to keep them. There's a huge difference in the feel of both shoes. I find the Hawaiian ones are more casual (I think it's the print) for shorts and cute, quick outfits whereas I can see myself wearing the black Beks with some of the more refined looking pieces within my minimalist, Helmut Lang aesthetic. Leather pants, zara skorts, AW ruched skirt...things like that..and a lot of black and white.

