I need help deciding. Please help me as I can only afford one because I am supposedly on a ban.
I purchased the Noir Bayley before my ban. They are very cute, but they are noir and I already have the Willows in blue/black combo. But I love the noir bayley too because of the tea stain canvas with contrasting black seude and leather. I love the contrast which the Willows do not have. However, it is much more "boyish."
In a moment of weakness I pulled the trigger on the Ciel Bayleys. They are soooo pretty and feminine. However, they are light so easy to get dirty. Also, I am worried about versatility. I think it might be a color that can only be worn with whites, off whites or light colored pieces. Or skirts and shorts with blue in them. The bonus, because of the light color they make the legs look long when wearing skirts and shorts. The Noir Bayleys do not as much.
Noir Bayley:
Ceil Bayley:
So my questions to you all is this:
1) What colors could I wear with the Ciel bayleys?
2) if I can only keep one, which one should it be?
3) Or maybe return both and keep neither because they are redundant?
For the record my IM sneaker collection is this: Blue/Black Willows, Gris Beketts, Khaki Bobbys, Lilas Bobbys.
Picture of the blue/black Willows:
and Gris Beketts 
Thanks for your help!
I purchased the Noir Bayley before my ban. They are very cute, but they are noir and I already have the Willows in blue/black combo. But I love the noir bayley too because of the tea stain canvas with contrasting black seude and leather. I love the contrast which the Willows do not have. However, it is much more "boyish."
In a moment of weakness I pulled the trigger on the Ciel Bayleys. They are soooo pretty and feminine. However, they are light so easy to get dirty. Also, I am worried about versatility. I think it might be a color that can only be worn with whites, off whites or light colored pieces. Or skirts and shorts with blue in them. The bonus, because of the light color they make the legs look long when wearing skirts and shorts. The Noir Bayleys do not as much.
Noir Bayley:

Ceil Bayley:

So my questions to you all is this:
1) What colors could I wear with the Ciel bayleys?
2) if I can only keep one, which one should it be?
3) Or maybe return both and keep neither because they are redundant?
For the record my IM sneaker collection is this: Blue/Black Willows, Gris Beketts, Khaki Bobbys, Lilas Bobbys.
Picture of the blue/black Willows:


Thanks for your help!
Last edited: