Wow - Comey is doing veneer now too? I swear some older pairs of her ankle boots I had were real wood. Hrmph.Where did you purchase? It's possible they will replace. NAP asked me no questions when I returned mine. I think if the color was just the same underneath it wouldn't be nearly as big a deal. I just noticed my Comey's are peeling a bit but you really have to look closely to see it (yes, I have an ankle boot problem).
I got my Dickers from La Garconne which I feel like isn't as steller with customer service as NAP. I also purchased them in mid Oct 2012 - this color isn't available anymore so I don't think I could get a replacement. I purchase from NAP when I can but for whatever reason it seems La Garconne stocks more IM shoes so I've ended up ordering both pairs I own from them. If I end up getting another pair down the road I'll try and get them from NAP!