I had actually never handled a Kelly of any style until the other day. My first H bag is a Lindy and is very soft and unstructured. Tuesday I handled some Kellys and was a little disappointed that they were so very hard and structured. I almost walked out of the store until I looked at a Blue Jean togo Bolide. I loved the color and almost passed out when they brought me a 35 Kelly in Blue Jean. Needless to say, I am now the proud owner of a very beautiful and slightly edgy Blue Jean Kelly. I think it's truly a matter of how one is going to use the bag. I was shown a 40 in a very stern looking leather (sorry, "stern" is the only adjective I could think of) I realize now, the 40 was probably a Sellier not a Retourne and it was so structured that she reminded me of a brief case.
--Judy
I'm the same way. I love retourne Kellys in Togo or Clemence... The look is so modern, which I prefer.