Most of my bags were bought used. The others were mostly bought on sale or at the outlet. My most recent
Coach bag that I own is from 2016, so I have very little experience with recent Coach, but I haven't been blown away by the leather I've seen at a Coach store in the last few years. For me, the quality of the leather is the most important thing. Then the color and size matter. I don't like a lot of branding either. The quality of older Coach varies. I think it was great from the 1980s to about 2003, then it depends on the collection. Vintage styles that were remade after 2003 aren't as good quality as the originals. Many people love the 2006-2007 Legacy collection. Personally I love the 2007-2008 Bleecker collection. I have many bags from the 2012 Legacy collection but they aren't all the best quality. Factory bags from around then weren't very nice either. I think I've heard that factory bags are starting to be made with better leather.