If I can get another Goyard, it would definitely the Artois Mm. Like you I tend to gravitate towards black bags So I decided to go with grey this time.I didnt get the St. Louis, but I just purchased and received my grey Artois MM in the mail last week and I love it. I have so many black bags I wanted to change things up! The grey is perfect for summer and will also work well in the winter. The only thing that made me unsure at first is the additional cost for the grey, but I am happy I did it!