ID This Coach item! -- Post any Coach item name questions here! --

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hi Hyacinth, and Beenburned, I wanted to ask for your help. I have put together a guide a to dating and identifying vintage Coach bags, and I was wondering if you would mind looking at it and possibly telling me if there are things I missed. I know you are both very well respected Coach experts, and I am not, so I was hoping maybe you might wish to contribute.
I am normally active in the Rehab and Rescue Club part of the forums, so I haven't had much interaction with either of you, but your identifications and knowledge are touted in there quite often, so I thought I would venture out of my comfort zone and ask.
Thank you!
http://coachbagrehab.blogspot.com/2012/04/guide-to-dates-of-vintage-coach-bags.html
While I'm flattered that you're asking my advice on vintage bags, I'm not qualified to answer most of your questions. Both Hyacinth and DemRam are the real vintage and classic bag experts, with DemRam also having great knowledge of Bonnie Cashin bags.

With that said, I do have a few comments.

1. Regarding your post on April 20, I have a correction to make to the following: At the bottom of the page is a list of style numbers and names of most of the bags that have such a thing, of course style numbers were not assigned until 1994.

Prior to 1994, style numbers were assigned to bags but they weren't used as part of the serial number on creeds until 1994, but instead, random serial numbers were used.

2. Regarding your post on April16 concerning a fake bag you received that day, you stated: I got a pretty good quality fake vintage Coach today from e-bay. I thought I would document what it looks like for reference purposes. It is a good fake like I said, so it could probably fool most people.

Although some of the Korean fakes are decent quality leather bags, as far as being "good fake Coach" bags, that they definitely are NOT. They use invalid serial numbers, creeds have improper fonts and spacing and the fact that they are made in Korea is a dead giveaway that the bag is fake.

Coach has many rules and just about every rule has exceptions, but the one rule without any exception is the rule that says that Coach has NEVER made a bag in Korea.

---------------

I'll defer to the real experts for further comments.

Good luck!
 
Mine did not have a horse and carriage fob, but the one my friend bought in HK did, which I find very strange. Mine had a "coach" fob , and hers had a coach and horse carriage fob. I just googled the Mia Maggie and it's not it. It looks totally like the current maggie. But the current strap is thin and this one is a bit twisted, it's wide and very soft leather. I know it once came in many colors. My friend has it in yellow and I have it in Black.

What is the number on the coach creed patch inside the bag?
 
While I'm flattered that you're asking my advice on vintage bags, I'm not qualified to answer most of your questions. Both Hyacinth and DemRam are the real vintage and classic bag experts, with DemRam also having great knowledge of Bonnie Cashin bags.

With that said, I do have a few comments.

1. Regarding your post on April 20, I have a correction to make to the following: At the bottom of the page is a list of style numbers and names of most of the bags that have such a thing, of course style numbers were not assigned until 1994.

Prior to 1994, style numbers were assigned to bags but they weren't used as part of the serial number on creeds until 1994, but instead, random serial numbers were used.

2. Regarding your post on April16 concerning a fake bag you received that day, you stated: I got a pretty good quality fake vintage Coach today from e-bay. I thought I would document what it looks like for reference purposes. It is a good fake like I said, so it could probably fool most people.

Although some of the Korean fakes are decent quality leather bags, as far as being "good fake Coach" bags, that they definitely are NOT. They use invalid serial numbers, creeds have improper fonts and spacing and the fact that they are made in Korea is a dead giveaway that the bag is fake.

Coach has many rules and just about every rule has exceptions, but the one rule without any exception is the rule that says that Coach has NEVER made a bag in Korea.

---------------

I'll defer to the real experts for further comments.

Good luck!

Thank you so much for your response, I added in what you said about style numbers and credited you for the correction!

And, I completely agree with what you say about fakes, I didn't mean the bag was a good bag, just that in photos it looked like the real thing, and it is a good example of what is out there for the unsuspecting.
 
Thank you so much for your response, I added in what you said about style numbers and credited you for the correction!

And, I completely agree with what you say about fakes, I didn't mean the bag was a good bag, just that in photos it looked like the real thing, and it is a good example of what is out there for the unsuspecting.
You're welcome.

I have another comment that is really important and Hyacinth is probably the one who deserves credit for it.

Be sure to keep your blog updated. Coach makes so many changes so unless your blog is current, you'll risk having it become as inaccurate and/or obsolete as so many other guides permeating the internet.
 
I also have a suggestion - help educate Coach owners and buyers to the amazing amount of misinformation and just plain LIES that are spread out over the internet in the form of unresearched, Copy & Pasted "authenticity guides", starting with the nonsense about YKK zippers.

A warning about the mistakes in the vast majority of those Guides might help, and a link to the two Salearea Guides on the subject would help even more. Of course, if you use the information in the Guides please credit the source and the author.
http://reviews.ebay.com/Coach-and-the-YKK-Zipper-Myth-the-Basic-Facts?ugid=10000000040073710
and
http://reviews.ebay.com/Coach-Authenticity-Guides-Facts-and-Myths?ugid=10000000062607882
 
I am new to this site & I'm not sure if I am in the right forum. I saw this wristlet on Ebay but there is no info as to the name or item # so I can look it up elsewhere. I can't seem to find any others like it which leads me to believe that it is a fake. Especially since the seller has 0 feedback, however, my daughter loves it & I would like to know if it is real & if so what is the name of this color/style. Any help would be greatly appreciated!
 

Attachments

  • coachorange.jpg
    coachorange.jpg
    9.9 KB · Views: 220
I am new to this site & I'm not sure if I am in the right forum. I saw this wristlet on Ebay but there is no info as to the name or item # so I can look it up elsewhere. I can't seem to find any others like it which leads me to believe that it is a fake. Especially since the seller has 0 feedback, however, my daughter loves it & I would like to know if it is real & if so what is the name of this color/style. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

The photo is too small and doesn't show enough detail. We can't identify or authenticate it without more photos. When asking for authenticity opinions you should really use the Authenticate This Coach found under Coach Shopping.

We need to see the Ebay listing especially if there are more photos of the wristlet. What little I can see would make me really reluctant to bid on it at any price, the strap alone just doesn't "feel" right. And buying from a 0-Feedback seller without a TON of photos and information is never a good idea.
 
Thanks so much. I wasn't sure if I was posting in the right thread, I will be sure to go to the proper one next time. I appreciate the advice. That is the only picture posted on the listing & there is no further information.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/26100912913...DX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1431.l2649#ht_500wt_1344
That is listing, I cut & pasted it from my address line. Again, thanks so much!

Thanks!

I haven't seen that color before but that doesn't mean much. Maybe someone else recognises it? There isn't another one like it on Ebay right now either.

I just can't be even halfway sure it's genuine, and the seller's hand is hiding a part of the strap that I'd like to see. Maybe someone else with authentication experience can take a look?
 
Last edited:
Thanks!

I haven't seen that color before but that doesn't mean much. Maybe someone else recognises it? There isn't another one like it on Ebay right now either.

I just can't be even halfway sure it's genuine, and the seller's hand is hiding a part of the strap that I'd like to see. Maybe someone else with authentication experience can take a look?

I think it's a Daisy wristlet (MFF) but pics aren't too good - here's a similar one

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dl...kD2aSmUD77WHr9f5HfIzo%3D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc
 
Top