So now the policy for accepting a bag for refurbish or repair is stricter?
I think that answer to your question is that it depends.
My bag was rejected without even a glance at the Madison Avenue store but accepted with no issue at the Atlanta boutique -- in fact, they admired the vintage bag a bit. (Ironically, the local boutique will send it to the Madison Avenue store before it goes on to Paris.) I am not sure what the official policy is, and it sounds like the employees at the boutique may or may not be familiar with the products or policies, so I guess it just depends on the boutique and who you happen to be working with on any given day.