Help me pick between these two?

For everyday, back and forth to work I'd go with the carryall.... the zipper can be a hassle at times, but you can put more things in it. I sometimes throw my water bottle or whatever book I'm reading in my bag. Also there is space to reach down in the bag even if it is all the way zipped up.
 
Thanks for the wonderful replies! I appreciate them and the thoughts that you took time to write!

Am going with the Carryall! I was leaning towards the satchel and my hubby liked the carryall and my daughter didn't like either. :rolleyes: Will call my "local" (3 hours away!) Coach store tomorrow and order it. They told me to always call them and I won't have to pay shipping. Also ordering a few other of the new items! :yes:

Thank you all so much! I love this forum!
 
I would pick this one.

#1 HAMPTONS SIGNATURE PERFORATED LARGE CARRYALL
10508_B4BK-1_d2.jpg
 
Thanks again everybody! I ordered the carryall today! :yahoo:

Also getting a couple of charms AND the Hampton's Weekend tote in green! I sure hope I like it IRL because I LOVE it on the website!

She said I'll get the black signature Carryall in a couple of days along with the charms but the tote will be a bit longer.