Same dilemma, was looking for a rectangular shaped watch. Was contemplating a vintage Cartier St Louis Tank. Somehow as I browse though the internet, the JLC just grew on me. I'm leaning more towards a JLC as it has serious watch cred as compared to Cartier being a jewelry brand. I have thin wrists and most watches tend to be overwhelming on me. Trends come and go but smaller watch generally gives a more polished and classy look. To be better able to read the time without my reading glasses, I"ll have to get a watch face with more contrast though.