Help! Bag and wallet dilemma....

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

jade

O.G.
Jan 15, 2006
1,571
1,376
So a little back story. Not long ago I identified I wanted a bag to fill the niche of a Chanel Flap bag. I wanted a dressy but dress down-able bag that had multiple carrying options, and a chain strap. The one certainty was that it wasn’t going to be a Chanel bag. The myriad of reasons are off topic for this thread.

I have a list of things considered. I ended up getting the bag I hoped would do it: Mulberry Cheyne. But just like Goldilocks, it turns out it isn’t quite right.

So heading jnto the new year, it was time for me to find a new holy grail for this purpose and make my 2019 aspiration list.

I udpated my requirements to chain strap (leather mix optional), big enough for my regular wallet, lotion, eye drops, lip product, work badge, reusable bag, notebook, pen, keys. Sunglasses are optional, but not a must have for me. of course crossbody and multiple carrying options. And leather or suede lining. Gold or gunmeta hardware. And black leather - not suede. This bag needs to look and feel premum. Also something less common than Chanel.

And I thought about revisiting my old choice - the Diorama. I hadn’t seen it in person but it has promise. As did the Fendi Kan I.

So I started looking. I visited all the premier brands. The lesser known threads. The department stores. And I found a contender on pre-order at Neiman Marcus: Akris Anouk. I decided to check out the Akris site abd found that most of that line met my requirements, but the size was a little iffy. The biggest one was only python (I’d love python but it is banned in my state). And a shade that didn’t look black.

So as I looked for other sources and reviews, I came across an unknown version for under $600 on a sketchy looking site. The one in the size I was looking at was $2300. So it seemed to good to be true. The pictures looked legit. I couldn’t find any info on the exact model number, but I found some similar model numbers. The bag I got was an all leather version of this one.

It arrived today. And it is almost perfect, save 3 things.
1. the bag was labeled new, with tags. And this is true, save a few tiny scratches on the hardware from a little bit of use. Most of the protective covering was still there.
2.The care card is in Japanese
3. The site labeled it the “day bag” but it is the smaller “city” bag

And here in lies the dilemma. The day bag size seemed like a good size but maybe a bit of a squeeze, I thought the other sizes were two small. The newer size lineup is a little diffferent and a bit wider than what I got.

So my essentials almost fit. There are some compromises. If I use my mid-sized wallet, I don’t quite have room for my reusable bag. If I use a small wallet, everything fits with ease. But for me small wallet = ocassion bag. And I might have enoigh of those, but this one is bigger than the ones I have and has a different hardware color. So it could fill a gap, my other plain black bags have gold hardware, and this one has the dark gunmetal shade. The crossbody length is great and I love the top handle. Tbe leather is beautiful and Iike tbe structure.

My medium wallet is a recent addition and it has been one of my favorite wallets ever. Albeit kinda big. From a functionality stand point it is great. But bur it does take up a lot of room for a wallet of its size and capacity. But it is pretty.

So now here is what I need to decide.
1. Return the bag, hope Akris releases a Day-sized bag in black (there isn’t one on the website now) and hope the size works. It would be about 3 cm longer and 3 cm wider than the one I have. And more expensive.
2. Make it a special ocassion only bag, and keep looking
3. Find a holy grail wallet that is a little smaller, use my small wallet in the meanwhile. Know that the new holy grail wallet would open up more bags in my collection for regular duty.
4. Find another bag to fill this niche.
5. Lose the reusable bag on my essentials list and play bag tetris with the wallet

I’m leaning towards #3, I have spent $1100 give or take on the wallet and bag, and the hylothetical bigger bag would cost $2400 plus tax. So it is cheaper to get a new wallet. And $1300 gets a serious wallet!

**Ok making this thread has pushed me over. I have decided to keep the bag, it is too pretty and the price is to great to give up. Even if it is only a weekend party bag, I could still make it work. I feel like this wallet has actually made me artificially limit my bag choices. So maybe it is actually the issue.
 
Here are a few pics of my stuff.
df715ea88339880f89d4c18f473023aa.jpg


Above is essentially the stuff I want to put in. The little black/white polka dot pouch is kinda optional. I can remove the stuff or fit in slightly different stuff. The grey wallet is the big one. The pink card holder of course is the mini.

44395a21aee9c141380554506789e5fd.jpg

^ big wallet

4394d69cfadc3090f24ccad23b17b222.jpg

^ little wallet. The pouch also fits with the little wallet.
 
You have a lot of requirements for this bag that limits your options and turns you into a Goldilocks. To begin with, not all brands make a Chanel-type bag and you have ruled out Chanel. In addition, the requirement of a leather or suede lining will limit you to a handful of premium brands. I think it would be a lot easier for you to find a small wallet you love as all the luxury brands make them and you will have more choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sparkletastic
You have a lot of requirements for this bag that limits your options and turns you into a Goldilocks. To begin with, not all brands make a Chanel-type bag and you have ruled out Chanel. In addition, the requirement of a leather or suede lining will limit you to a handful of premium brands. I think it would be a lot easier for you to find a small wallet you love as all the luxury brands make them and you will have more choices.

I know am being super picky. While I said no Chanel, I’m really looking for something mid-sized that works day to evening. I had previously purchased and returned. Chloe Faye bag and JW Anderson Pierce bags. The Pierce was so close but I disliked the lack of formal closure. I also have a Longchamp Amazone in burgundy. Good size, no leather lining which makes it not feel premium for me.

It seems like all of the bags I have considered are the same size as well. Going bigger doesn’t hit my niche.

I hadn’t completely set a budget yet, and this Akris deal popped up.

And it really solves for the things that have bothered me in other bags: not too many sections/dividers. And a phone sized back pocket. The chain is also removable. I like the subtle top handle too.


There was definitely a time when a Chanel flap was the ticket. But in reality I found it too heavy, too cramped and not discreet enough for me. And the price of course is very expensive. If Chanel made a leather lined Boy, with a re-issue closure and subtle chain that would probably be a winner. Lol.
 
I’ve never been to the outlet, this was purchased online. This chain flap style did give me the Chanel vibe. I didn’t really see others that reminded me of Chanel, which did you see?

Oh man, the outlet had tweed jackets, tweet suits, two tone ballet flats. Your bag was there as well as a myriad of chain/quilted leather bags. 85% of stuff had a Chanel hallmark in one way or another.

I had seen various shoes and clothing items at Macy’s and the like that didn’t seem so derivative so it was a shock to see such an explosion.

Michael Kors’ chain bag take is pretty good. It doesn’t have the premium lining, but the branding is subtle and the shape is nice.

https://www.michaelkors.com/whitney...ble-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_30H8BWHL3T?color=2597

This Collection one is really pretty as well. I am not a silver hardware person these days.
https://www.michaelkors.com/bancroft-python-and-calf-leather-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_31F8TBNL4G
 
Oh man, the outlet had tweed jackets, tweet suits, two tone ballet flats. Your bag was there as well as a myriad of chain/quilted leather bags. 85% of stuff had a Chanel hallmark in one way or another.

I had seen various shoes and clothing items at Macy’s and the like that didn’t seem so derivative so it was a shock to see such an explosion.

Michael Kors’ chain bag take is pretty good. It doesn’t have the premium lining, but the branding is subtle and the shape is nice.

https://www.michaelkors.com/whitney...ble-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_30H8BWHL3T?color=2597

This Collection one is really pretty as well. I am not a silver hardware person these days.
https://www.michaelkors.com/bancroft-python-and-calf-leather-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_31F8TBNL4G
Gotcha! I don’t know if they have the outlets in my area. I saw a picture of the bag and fell in love. It took me ages to find out who made it since the branding was almost non existent!
Macy’s is having a sale right now on MK bags and there are quite a few leather chain flap bags, I tried on several that were quite pretty and under $200!
 
Well I had to go to the outlets to return something, so I decided to peruse Barney's, Prada, Gucci and Bottega Veneta. I ended up finding a winner at BV - and that brand was on my wallet aspiration list! A suitable replacement for the Valextra one I have that is too big!

*I am equally picky about wallets these days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amazona
I know am being super picky. While I said no Chanel, I’m really looking for something mid-sized that works day to evening. I had previously purchased and returned. Chloe Faye bag and JW Anderson Pierce bags. The Pierce was so close but I disliked the lack of formal closure. I also have a Longchamp Amazone in burgundy. Good size, no leather lining which makes it not feel premium for me.

It seems like all of the bags I have considered are the same size as well. Going bigger doesn’t hit my niche.

I hadn’t completely set a budget yet, and this Akris deal popped up.

And it really solves for the things that have bothered me in other bags: not too many sections/dividers. And a phone sized back pocket. The chain is also removable. I like the subtle top handle too.


There was definitely a time when a Chanel flap was the ticket. But in reality I found it too heavy, too cramped and not discreet enough for me. And the price of course is very expensive. If Chanel made a leather lined Boy, with a re-issue closure and subtle chain that would probably be a winner. Lol.
I like the idea of the Chanel boy with leather lining and and a closure!
 
Oh man, the outlet had tweed jackets, tweet suits, two tone ballet flats. Your bag was there as well as a myriad of chain/quilted leather bags. 85% of stuff had a Chanel hallmark in one way or another.

I had seen various shoes and clothing items at Macy’s and the like that didn’t seem so derivative so it was a shock to see such an explosion.

Michael Kors’ chain bag take is pretty good. It doesn’t have the premium lining, but the branding is subtle and the shape is nice.

https://www.michaelkors.com/whitney...ble-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_30H8BWHL3T?color=2597

This Collection one is really pretty as well. I am not a silver hardware person these days.
https://www.michaelkors.com/bancroft-python-and-calf-leather-shoulder-bag/_/R-US_31F8TBNL4G
I agree! I'm not usually a MK fan, but when I saw the Vivianne in the outlet, I was excited to buy it! I would say the MK has a lot of good, affordable alternatives to Chanel-like flap bags, and the outlet has them for slightly cheaper (for me, the Sloan version of my bag is lamb leather but the outlet version Vivianne is calf).

 
Top