This is an interesting question you ask, when I purchased the blue bag preloved, I did 2 third party authentications and one resulted in a fake outcome, one said authentic. I requested the company I purchased off to redo their assessment, so after being authenticated by 3 out of 4 specialists, the bag was deemed authentic. I had so many questions, the bag, the type of leather, the "plastic smell" etc. They kindly answered all my questions and I kept the bag in the end, have you noticed the leather structure of this bag is softer - which made me think it was fake. It totally sits differently to the other calf leather pandoras i own. Anyway, long story short, it was explained to me that the leather of this style is specially treated to create a "wrinkled" effect. So that's why it looks different to the distressed leather pandora, it's a different treatment and not pebbled and not exactly distressed. I completely understand your question! I had the same exact ones. I hope this helps fellow Pandora fan.