YYZ, appreciate your detail inputs on the matter of short or tall Jenna. The dilemmas I am facing are given that I am in the 'back to basic' mode for next few years, I really need Frye to handle the four seasons MI has to offer. What I love about the tall boots are that it keeps me warm in thin summer jeans I brought from TX, does not dig into my leg when I walk as short/ankle boots do yet I can sit comfortably without it hitting the back of my knee, slim fit so little chance of snow/rain drips in. Yet it is so slim that it's a chore to pull it on/off (having to actually sit on a chair and do the wiggle thing in front of SO, it's like doing the wiggle to pry a pair of jeans on :giggles

, may be too heavy to wear during spring/summer seasons? And I don't have any short boots aside from the Vera Strappy.
Now the short boots is so easy to pull on/off, I can see myself wearing it in summer/spring too, plus I am lacking in short boots department. The flip side is I think my legs look stubby in it (or may be because I'm not used to seeing it on myself?), the opening of shaft could be a problem during snow/rain time.