E-ring upgrade

[limom]

Ring #1
This is similar to my own engagement ring that I have been wearing for over thirty years.
I still love it.
As far as ring #2, it is nice but not with a canary diamond, imo.
I would get sick and tired of looking at it every day.

 

[Hurrem1001]

Hey guys, out of the following two which would you pick? I understand they are both very different items with different looks however I am so indecisive.

Option 1:
- 3 carat+ low color (u-v) cushion cut solitaire

Option 2:
- trade in my original e-ring and get a Tiffany yellow diamond soleste double halo with a centre stone between 1-1.5 carats

I can only pick one. Option 1 will be like an antique style warm diamond (which I love).

My ring size is 3.5 and I currently have a round brilliant 2 carat stone.

Personally I love big diamonds and lots of finger coverage.

I love option one. Simply beautiful.