Dooney FLORENTINE Clubhouse!!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Viv: sometimes it's hard to know why you just aren't sure if you love a handbag enough to keep it.
And it may or may not have anything to do with the bag itself. There is no such thing as
'all other things being equal' in this life anymore. And if we are expecting a bag to look a certain
way or are super excited about it, then it might not live up to our expectations.
The more expensive the handbag is, the more we want to be sure we are making
the right decision.

With the Barlow and the Brenna (and the Flynn) the shape of the bag out of the
box doesn't show the bag to it's greatest potential. It's sort of a slouchy/structured mix,
with curves/ruffles, etc. And it's rarely stuffed enough to show all it's beauty.

With this kind of style, I really need to put my items inside to see how the bag will look
in real life. After all, I don't carry around styrofoam to perk up the shape.

It's taken me a while to come to appreciate the look, and I think for me,
the functionality of the design has made the style a good one. I try not to focus
too much on the lack of symmetry or the wrinkles that are part of the style.
I've learned that the zip Barlow and the large Barlow are too heavy for me now,
but the regular size Barlow and Brenna are good for me. The small and mini aren't
big enough to hold my stuff.

Also, very often the Florentine leather looks better after it has been handled and
softens up. Just out of the box, sitting in plastic, after being subjected to cold temperatures
and lots of jostling, the leather needs some TLC. I don't condition new Flo bags, but
I have been known to give them a gentle rubdown with a soft, dry, white cloth. It brings out
the natural oils in the leather, and improves the look and feel.

I've also discovered that when I get a new bag I'm very picky and notice every
little bitty thing. Once I start using a bag, many of those first impression defects
just seem to fade into the background and I no longer see them. So I've learned to try
to separate out major flaws and substantial issues from more minor cosmetic ones.
It's all subjective, and what bothers me someone else might not notice or care, and vice versa.

You are right to take some time to decide if the bag is a keeper.
If you package it up to return it and feel better, then that was a good decision.
If you package it up and then take the bag back out, then you know
you will probably regret returning it. The act of preparing the return often
helps me decide. If I feel relief that the bag is going back, I know that's the
right decision.
 
Viv: sometimes it's hard to know why you just aren't sure if you love a handbag enough to keep it.
And it may or may not have anything to do with the bag itself. There is no such thing as
'all other things being equal' in this life anymore. And if we are expecting a bag to look a certain
way or are super excited about it, then it might not live up to our expectations.
The more expensive the handbag is, the more we want to be sure we are making
the right decision.

With the Barlow and the Brenna (and the Flynn) the shape of the bag out of the
box doesn't show the bag to it's greatest potential. It's sort of a slouchy/structured mix,
with curves/ruffles, etc. And it's rarely stuffed enough to show all it's beauty.

With this kind of style, I really need to put my items inside to see how the bag will look
in real life. After all, I don't carry around styrofoam to perk up the shape.

It's taken me a while to come to appreciate the look, and I think for me,
the functionality of the design has made the style a good one. I try not to focus
too much on the lack of symmetry or the wrinkles that are part of the style.
I've learned that the zip Barlow and the large Barlow are too heavy for me now,
but the regular size Barlow and Brenna are good for me. The small and mini aren't
big enough to hold my stuff.

Also, very often the Florentine leather looks better after it has been handled and
softens up. Just out of the box, sitting in plastic, after being subjected to cold temperatures
and lots of jostling, the leather needs some TLC. I don't condition new Flo bags, but
I have been known to give them a gentle rubdown with a soft, dry, white cloth. It brings out
the natural oils in the leather, and improves the look and feel.

I've also discovered that when I get a new bag I'm very picky and notice every
little bitty thing. Once I start using a bag, many of those first impression defects
just seem to fade into the background and I no longer see them. So I've learned to try
to separate out major flaws and substantial issues from more minor cosmetic ones.
It's all subjective, and what bothers me someone else might not notice or care, and vice versa.

You are right to take some time to decide if the bag is a keeper.
If you package it up to return it and feel better, then that was a good decision.
If you package it up and then take the bag back out, then you know
you will probably regret returning it. The act of preparing the return often
helps me decide. If I feel relief that the bag is going back, I know that's the
right decision.
Thank you for your thoughtful response! You are SOOO right about preparing the return forcing you to call the question lol. I've decided to keep it as heavy bags don't bother me at all and I appreciate the ease of access that so many folks mention about this bag. You can't go wrong with Florentine! And by the way, I have to say that the folks on this D&B thread are the kindest and most humble of any PurseForum thread I've experienced.
 
The advice lavenderj gave me above on my brown tmoro Logan helped me so much to decide. I returned it as it really was too textured and dull in person for me. I wasnt reaching for it at all. I dont mind imperfections but i just didnt like this bag even with the great sale. I got a Chestnut Florentine Logan instead and I Absolutely love it!

Agreed. If I don’t reach for it. I sell it. Lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lunalark
Thank you for your thoughtful response! You are SOOO right about preparing the return forcing you to call the question lol. I've decided to keep it as heavy bags don't bother me at all and I appreciate the ease of access that so many folks mention about this bag. You can't go wrong with Florentine! And by the way, I have to say that the folks on this D&B thread are the kindest and most humble of any PurseForum thread I've experienced.
How do you manage the weight? Do you limit how much you put in to the bag? When I had one it just didn’t work for me. Maybe a mini Barlow would have worked better?
 
I agree, the ladies here on the D&B board are great.... helpful and generous with their time.
We all learn as we go, and it's great to have others with more experience to give us input.
No one is shamed for not knowing something. Handbags are a fun hobby, and we all want
to make the best decisions, but you can be a genius and not know what a twilly is (I didn't, not
a genius either)
or why a particular type of leather is considered good.

I also think that posters here recognize that everyone has different needs, likes,
finances, etc. We try to offer info, so that others can make the right decision for themselves.
That's really important.... for example, it may not matter to me if the strap drop is short, since I hand carry my bags, but I try to remember to point it out because it's important to lots of others.

Many posters have moved on to other social media venues. But some of us still
hang around here. It's always great to have newer posters join the conversation.
Talking about handbags is fun, but a conversation needs at least 2
people. And the more the merrier.
 
How do you manage the weight? Do you limit how much you put in to the bag? When I had one it just didn’t work for me. Maybe a mini Barlow would have worked better?
You know, I've never picked up a handbag and thought it was TOO heavy. The only thing I really need in a bag is a good long strap so I can throw it over the shoulder if I need help with weight. I just favor large bags (I think they make you look smaller/thinner lol), so weight has never really been an issue. I also only wear my fancy bags to work, and I've only got the "commute" between the parking deck and my office to worry about (3 mins?). On the weekends, like today, when I'm out shopping or running errands, I carry my black Longchamp Le Pliage Neo in large. It is super lightweight, and has a convenient zipper and shoulder straps. So, I guess, in a way, I do care about weight. I guess I just don't care about weight when it comes to fancy bags because I only ever wear them for brief periods. I'm also always wearing some sort of athleisure (with 3 large and super active dogs, I run/walk/workout a lot) during the weekends, so I think a fancy bag would just look out of place. The Longchamp very nicely bridges the gap between casual and formal in a classy way. Hopefully that makes sense? Please excuse the super long winded dissertation-esque answer to your question lol.
 
I'm so glad you are happy with your decision! That's the most important part. And the more Florentine ages it just might become a favorite bag of yours I forgot to mention when a bag of mine had a crease (came from mailing) I stuffed it full with t shirts and paper against the creases extra for a few days. Maybe that will help idk. It is a beautiful bag. Like you i am ok with weight. The large barlow balances well for me. But I tend to like easy in/out shoulder bag carrying. I think its just individual needs, if you prefer shoulder vs satchel carry etc. And how long you are wearing it for absolutely... I wouldn't walk the dog with it probably not :) .

I wouldn't know half of how to care for my bags, the leathers, styles etc if not for the wonderful posters here! Always helpful&lovely to chat with ❤ It is fun to view the older pages of mod shots too. The amazing collections are purse lovers heaven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Viv99
You know, I've never picked up a handbag and thought it was TOO heavy. The only thing I really need in a bag is a good long strap so I can throw it over the shoulder if I need help with weight. I just favor large bags (I think they make you look smaller/thinner lol), so weight has never really been an issue. I also only wear my fancy bags to work, and I've only got the "commute" between the parking deck and my office to worry about (3 mins?). On the weekends, like today, when I'm out shopping or running errands, I carry my black Longchamp Le Pliage Neo in large. It is super lightweight, and has a convenient zipper and shoulder straps. So, I guess, in a way, I do care about weight. I guess I just don't care about weight when it comes to fancy bags because I only ever wear them for brief periods. I'm also always wearing some sort of athleisure (with 3 large and super active dogs, I run/walk/workout a lot) during the weekends, so I think a fancy bag would just look out of place. The Longchamp very nicely bridges the gap between casual and formal in a classy way. Hopefully that makes sense? Please excuse the super long winded dissertation-esque answer to your question lol.
Makes perfect sense! Yes I can manage a large bag to and from the car to work. Weekends I move into my Allison’s so I can move quickly in and out as I run around. One thing I have noticed which LJ made reference to months ago, the satchels with the flat base like my mini sit very well in the car. The old school rounded satchels tend to roll and not sit so well. The Barlow has a flat base. Super helpful!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Viv99
Quick question. How have your flo bags held up over the years? In terms of wear and tear? Anyone have pictures of flo bags that are several years old? I am curious as I have quite a collection.
 
I have a question I hope someone can answer for me about a python satchel. I bought it on ebay for a good price but it had a ton of ink marks inside. So, I pulled the lining out to clean it and after it was dry I went to push it back inside. The thing is, it feels like there's another layer between the outside of the bag and the lining. Is it maybe a piece that fits across the bottom? I think this is a medium size. I don't have any other satchels this big to compare it to. Any help is appreciated!
 
I don't know for sure, but my guess is that it's something to give structure to the bottom
of the handbag. The sides are probably a soft slouchy style, but the base is likely firm
on a satchel design. I don't know what it would be made of.... could be a firmer textile,
like buckram, or some synthetic material. Hopefully it's not cardboard or something that
got damaged during the cleaning.

BTW, I love the Dooney python satchels. What color did you get?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ljg80827
Top