Does your SA make you feel guilty when you make a return?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I used to work in high-end retail and I am a big shopper and I don't think that a SA should have any problem with returns, nor should I feel bad about doing them. It's just a fact of life, sometimes things don't work out! Do they own the company? Even if they work on comission, they should realize that good customers will buy more if you treat them well! Sorry for the rant but I really hate when SAs think they can give you attitude because you're returning something. :rant: :p
 
TheArtofAcquisition said:
We all know the pitfalls and benefits of the commission system which causes some SAs to kiss our behinds the second we gaze their direction or at the merchandise. We may have even worked in retail and understand how difficult it is to secure the client, and then disappointing it is to get a return.

I recently went to Nordstroms and the shoe salesman proposed to me - not marriage, well...maybe. After walking in the door he remembered me from a previous visit and immediately greeted me, "June 14!" (the day of my birthday, which he oddly remembered though we had spoken briefly). He then proceeded to do what I sometimes unkindly call the "shoe dance" where a shoe salesman begins to falsely praise your sense of style, present possible shoes regardless of how they look or whether they are wise choices, tell you how fabulous you are though they have never met you before etc etc otherwise known as the "give me your credit card now dance". (The best shoe-salesmen will not do the dance, they will be honest with you about what looks good, and be honest about which shoes are good choices.) The conversation ended with the most hilarious proclamation of his affection for me... "Please, please let me be your shoe man." At that exact moment my boyfriend had walked in the store and was standing a few feet away from us. I felt as though I was cheating on him as I was mentally chuckling, answering the salesman in my thoughts, "Yes, you can be my Shoe Man, and I will be your Shoe Woman... and we can have Shoe Children." Haha.

Anyway, this man is just one example of what the commission system has reduced salespeople to at times. Another "Shoe Man" (now he sounds like a super-hero) I encountered that day told me about his many children, and his hard life, and praised me for making his day with my purchases and told me I was a true lady and that he could not wait for me to come back. I felt overwhelmed and nervous... I was buying sale shoes... what if I wanted to return something? What if I saw something from Pre-Fall next week at a different shop and took these sale shoes back... would his children starve because I snatched away, cruelly, his commission? That is how he made me feel. Or perhaps I'm too sensitive? Is it wrong to care too much?

I suppose the point of my tangent is does anyone else buy a lot and then think about it at home, eventually making returns? Does this make you feel guilty? Uneasy? Or should we not care? Or is it more wrong for the salesperson to put you in a position to feel guilty, or to treat you differently if you make returns?

What about salespeople that don't want to sell you something if you are not sure and give you attitude if you say, "I'll take it home and think about it"? Today a Chanel SA told me that if I was not sure that my mother wanted the bag I was about to get for her, that would not be a good thing, and I should just leave it. My mother asked me to buy it so she could look at it, not so that she could marry it!

Rude !
 
Wow, I'm not sure what to say about this comment and am hoping that I am misreading it!

ArtofAcquisition - You shouldn't feel bad about returning. That's just part of the business. Some SA's do try to guilt you into keeping it, but what good SA's realize is all this does is breed resentment. My SA at NM is a sweetheart and we had a talk about this. I told her frankly that I HATED (which I do) returning stuff, so I want to be darn sure that the bag is what I want prior to leaving the store. Knowing this, she was far more understanding when I made a return because she knew how much I disliked to do that. Of course, I buy a heck of a lot more from her too.
 
Right now I am feeling very badly about a return I made today - the SA went out of her way for me - but when I got it home, I couldn't justify it - just didn't love it enough - the SA was out today (I didn't know that) when I returned it and of course I ended up buying a bag from Dior where the commission went to a different person - why do I torture myself? I feel so guilty. Maybe it's better not to hook up with a SA in the first place.
 
Next time you're in the store, it couldn't hurt to ask who gets the commission when you return one item and buy something else. I worked high-end retail, and the original sales associate would get the commission on the second item. It was store policy, and if you tried to steal the commission for yourself, you'd be fired.

SuzyZ said:
Right now I am feeling very badly about a return I made today - the SA went out of her way for me - but when I got it home, I couldn't justify it - just didn't love it enough - the SA was out today (I didn't know that) when I returned it and of course I ended up buying a bag from Dior where the commission went to a different person - why do I torture myself? I feel so guilty. Maybe it's better not to hook up with a SA in the first place.
 
My handbag SA at NM is terrific. She will call me when hard to find stuff comes in and,if I can't get there fast, will charge it to me. If I don't like it, I just return it -- she is totally cool with it. Sometimes she will ask me to bring it back when she is there because she has another customer who might want it.
My shoe guy is great too.
But, like a few people have said, these SAs know I buy tons of stuff. And keep way more than I return. I think that knowing you can return something helps you buy alot more than you might otherwise buy. And most of the time you don't return it.
 
Ammietwist said:
Next time you're in the store, it couldn't hurt to ask who gets the commission when you return one item and buy something else. I worked high-end retail, and the original sales associate would get the commission on the second item. It was store policy, and if you tried to steal the commission for yourself, you'd be fired.
My - Saks has little separate boutiques within it - LV, Chanel and Dior - the first bag was purchased from Saks inventory and the SA who worked for Saks got it - the second bag came from the Dior boutique where the SA worked for Dior - He deserved the commission. No one tried to pull anything improper - I just fell for the Dior bag when I returned the first bag - so the first SA lost out. :sad:
 
digby723 said:
:rofl: :rofl: I loved that!!

I rarely do either, exchanging or returning, and when I do go to return, I normally just exchange it or something else. I do sometimes feel the pressure from SAs to purchase something, and have no started shopping w/ my ipod, so, when I "ignore" an SA b/c I'm just looking at something, I dont get pressured and they don't feel like I'm completely ignoring them, as I can't hear them b/c my music is too loud! :D

OMG I do the same exact thing!!!! :p

I always listen to my iPod and politely nod when I'm in a store in Japan. And they usually don't approach me when I'm listening to my iPod.
 
Top