So I loaded it up and there is no contest, I'm keeping this one. Here are some photos for what can fit inside. I can also use my smaller Kate Spade wallet, but it obviously takes up more square footage so my card case is the better for room. I got the call my regular sized arrived today so I'm headed to the store to officially return it.
Edit to add: My phone also comfortably fits in the front inner pocket, but for obvious reasons it is not in the photos.
View attachment 4085535View attachment 4085536