Diamond Studs
- Thread starter sdkitty
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
In this case, I'd go with your second option. It's only a $100 difference for something that you probably would never even notice with respect to the color or cut.
Option 2 was definitely a good choice. I love Blue Nile but have you checked out Brilliant Earth at all? Their a favorite of mine as well.
Thanks everyone, for the confirmation! Pair #2 are due to arrive tomorrow!
I'm SO excited because I did some reading on Pricescope (I used to be an active member just before getting engaged), and the feedback on BlueNile was lukewarm. However, I got a hold of some of the specs of my stones, plugged them into the HCA tool, and the stones scored 1.4 and 1.9 - both excellent scores! So I'm much more confident in my BN purchase... can't wait to see them in person tomorrow!
TylerDurden - thanks for your recommendation of Brilliant Earth! I've heard of it before, but didn't remember it when I was doing my search. I took a look - I appreciate what they represent. I'll definitely keep them in mind for my next purchase!
I'm SO excited because I did some reading on Pricescope (I used to be an active member just before getting engaged), and the feedback on BlueNile was lukewarm. However, I got a hold of some of the specs of my stones, plugged them into the HCA tool, and the stones scored 1.4 and 1.9 - both excellent scores! So I'm much more confident in my BN purchase... can't wait to see them in person tomorrow!
TylerDurden - thanks for your recommendation of Brilliant Earth! I've heard of it before, but didn't remember it when I was doing my search. I took a look - I appreciate what they represent. I'll definitely keep them in mind for my next purchase!
Thanks everyone for your comments! They arrived today and I'm super happy with them! They are SO sparkly and fiery... couldn't stop looking in the mirror! I do notice the ever-so-slight diff color when held up against my e-ring (I wouldn't say they're yellower, thought, just... different), but they appear white on my ears. No inclusions to my untrained eye (though I just ordered a loupe so I can look at these babies). I was afraid they'd be small-ish for my taste, but they are a comfortable size. These are so beautiful, and yet they're perfect for everyday wear! Here are some pics!
First off... a comparison between the new pair (pair #2 from orig post) and a pair that DH gifted me recently, and was kind enough to allow me to upgrade immediately.
New pair on top - 0.82 cttw, J, SI1, ideal cut. Platinum martini setting. BlueNile's build-your-own-diamond-earrings.
Bottom pair - approx 0.5 cttw, H, VS2, good cut. Platinum 4-prong basket setting. Pre-built pair... therefore, specs are approximate.
New pair compared to some diamond heart studs I've been wearing for the past few years. What a difference in cut, fire and brilliance! Not sure of hte cttw of the hearts, but thought this would be an interesting comparison.
New pair compared to my approx 1 ct G, VS2, AGS0 solitaire.
And finally, a modeling shot...
First off... a comparison between the new pair (pair #2 from orig post) and a pair that DH gifted me recently, and was kind enough to allow me to upgrade immediately.
New pair on top - 0.82 cttw, J, SI1, ideal cut. Platinum martini setting. BlueNile's build-your-own-diamond-earrings.
Bottom pair - approx 0.5 cttw, H, VS2, good cut. Platinum 4-prong basket setting. Pre-built pair... therefore, specs are approximate.
New pair compared to some diamond heart studs I've been wearing for the past few years. What a difference in cut, fire and brilliance! Not sure of hte cttw of the hearts, but thought this would be an interesting comparison.
New pair compared to my approx 1 ct G, VS2, AGS0 solitaire.
And finally, a modeling shot...
Attachments
