So, I think they are all going back to Blue Nile. I have hesitation with each one of them. Like I mentioned above, I think what I really want are diamond cuff earrings, or small diamond huggies. I want some blinginess with little to no drop below my lobes - something that won't get caught in something, have some width to them, with a secure closure. I prefer a few large stones over pave.
Of the ones from Blue Nile, I like #1 the most. If it had 3 stones instead of 5 in each earring, the drop would be more along the lines of what I want. I tried to find (online) small hoops with 3 large diamonds each, and I didn't find anything good. I'm not sure if what I'm looking for really exists, and I wonder if it doesn't exist for a good reason that I'm not thinking of?
I really like LeeMiller's costco pair a lot. It's double the total carat weight of Blue Nile #1, so it will be wider and maybe the drop will seem smaller because the stones are bigger? I guess it depends from where to where the size of the hoop is measured. Those look like they're round, but if there's only a small drop, then round is probably ok.
What do you ladies think?