hi may i know based in your own experience, which leather is more durable? us the smooth leather prone to scratch?
I have had the sand coloured smooth leather zipper tote for a couple of weeks now and I've used it a handful of times. I don't have any major scratches but if you look really closely you can see very minor surface scratches (so minor that I couldn't even photograph them for you). Also the bottom corners have darkened a little from what looks like colour transfer, but that is probably expected with most lighter coloured leather.
Overall though I am still very happy with this tote. I purchased mine at the San Fran show room so I was able to touch and feel all the leathers. I fell in love with the smooth leather because of how soft and buttery it was. Plus it had a zipper which is a necessity for me.