Do you need a smaller bag? I would probably just get the one bag and see how I liked it before I got another. Do you want or need two black bags? They are different styles and sizes so you might. Then again, maybe you'd like some variety so the cream is a better choice. Keep in mind that cream tends to work better in the summer and with lighter colored clothes. Also, the cream might be susceptible to color transfer, like from your jeans. It might be a pain to own because you'd have to be so careful with it.