I pretty much dunk any unlined bag. If the bag has lining, I'm more reticent. I also think twice about dunking really old collector's pieces.I have read a little about rehabbing on this site in the past. But I could not find any specific criteria for when to dunk and when not to dunk. I am one of those people who needs guidelines. I am not too creative on my own, lol.
And not too long ago, I took an old leather gun holster that my hubby had and dunked it. Then I did the CPR and Blackrock thing and it came out lovely. It had to be at least 75 years old. I was totally amazed. I don't have the bag in my hands yet, so it may have some musty smell, etc. Thanks for taking the time to answer. I appreciate it.
Your new bag has pig suede lining. It can get wet but I don't think the type of leather used on the exterior will benefit from a dunking. It's kind of like Dooney AWL.