While I don't disagree that many of rosemerrily 's listings are for non-coach items made using charms from butchered keychains, this particular listing isn't one of them.
The fob shown in this listing is style 1743 and is just one 3D handbag charm and enameled lozenge hangtag. It came in purple, blue and pink. (Pinks attached.)
There have been several multi charm handbag fobs but those were flat enameled charms.
A more important reason I would avoid both IDs, rosemerrily and creamsiclemolly is that she has had several listings for fake Coach keychains (since removed), a few of which have been scary "good" fakes, one of which was discussed in AT Coach. Some of her fakes are difficult even for the authenticators to identify as such.
Starts here: http://forum.purseblog.com/coach-shopping/authenticate-this-coach-889527-443.html#post28658869
It was mentioned here (somewhere) that she also removes hangtags from some of her fobs and sells the remaining item as "Coach." I'm guessing that the removals of the lozenges is so she can attach them to some of those fakes that she does list, as mentioned here:
http://forum.purseblog.com/coach-shopping/authenticate-this-coach-855067-481.html#post27392205
But again, the listing mentioned above by Zuggy appears to be authentic style 1743.
Sorry beenburned, but I have to disagree with you on this item. Her fob is not the one made to be sold on an individual keyring by itself....it is the tiny one that came on a chain of 3D handbags. It is much too small and the chain is wrong too.