Ha! Of course my PF ladies have a thread for Birkinstocks! I just found this thread last night. I've been on the fence lately...and fell over to the Birkenstock side last night. I got the Monterey Exquisite Black regular width from an ebay seller in the UK (she has a boutique there). I also have the narrow coming from Nordies (the page is bookmarked and I checked it daily until a 40 popped up!). I'm thinking I need the regular because the JCrew Birks are tad narrow on me.
btw luisaviaroma has the Monterey Exquisite Black in 39-45 for $237
I think you got my Nordstrom return. Glad they are going to a good home! I had ordered the 40 when they were still labeling them as a 9, and they were too big for me. Last night a 39 popped back up, hopefully they will ship.